I was the rude one (although I tried to hide my reaction).
I don't hunt, dislike team sports and was raised in the middle of a city. My father-in-law hunts, is into football and was raised on a farm.
His gifts to me on Christmas are always "off". Usually I put on a good face and donate it later, but last year...
I opened the first gift and it was this book
. For just a second my brain went "Why would he think I would be interested in this?" and I am sure my eyes narrowed. Then I remembered my manners, but I am sure he saw. Unfortunately the other gifts were about the same, but I recovered enough to make sure I didn't react as badly to them.