I have gone through my profile & un-notified every single topic except the few I have created.
Still I am getting notifications on the "What little things drive you completely up the wall" thread (which is ironic cause I find the fact it's there is irritating). Specifically, when I click the 'show new replies to your posts' link, this thread displays but it shouldn't based on my notify settings.
Why would that thread still be flagged to notify me when it is not in my listing of threads to notify me? Weirdly-worded question. Hope it makes sense.
If more threads other than "what little things...." display I will let you know, as the issue may be thread-specific.