Thanks so much to everyone for resurrecting this thread! I missed it the first time.
To those who miss B&BW fragrances that are discontinued: I am a soapmaker, and many of the soapmaking fragrance manufacturers have successfully duplicated the B&BW fragrances. Just reading through this thread, I went and found dupes online for:
Coconut Lime Verbena
Now, I don't own these scents, but I've got 'em on my "to buy" list now and if you want to pm me, I can let you know when your favorite fragrance is in stock in my soap shop. I do have a few cucumber melon already.
Or if you personally know a soapmaker, ask them if they can get you your favorite B&BW scent and make it into soap for you. I'm happy to make anyone a log of soap (about 12 bars) for $15 or so. Whenever someone I know makes a suggestion to me for a fragrance for soap, I usually give them a free bar in thanks after it's made.
Update: Someone's already asked for Coconut Lime Verbena and Dancing Waters so those scents are on the way, if anyone wants a log (or just a few bars) lemme know!