Lol! I imagine him reading the reply and going, "Hey, I said I was 'above-average' income, I'm not a millionaire! Oh, these shallow 'very attractive' women! They're only interested in one thing! Why won't they see me for my soul, not my bank account!"
But actually, I kind of blame this on Hef and the Playboy mentality. Many men have absorbed from such media that no matter what their attractions, they should be positively pursued by supermodels. After all, Hef's a withered old man, and look at the arm-candy he gets. Clearly, this is what all men are entitled to.
It's a math literacy problem. They can't quite figure out why if their standard is the top 1% of the population (that is, supermodels), 99% of the women they meet don't measure up.