Poll

What should a person do if proposed to in public and the answer is "No"?

Refuse Immediately in Public
108 (52.7%)
Accept in Public and Refuse at the earliest opportunity in private
50 (24.4%)
Other (Please Explain)
47 (22.9%)

Total Members Voted: 205

Author Topic: Public Marriage Proposals  (Read 18323 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Chivewarrior

  • Hero Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 1526
Re: Public Marriage Proposals
« Reply #120 on: May 08, 2013, 01:04:01 PM »
OK, made it to the end of the thread.

I hate these things because I think the proposal should be a private affair because it's about a relationship of private emotions.  I cringe during Moonstruck when Johnny Cammarreri proposed to Loretta in the Grand Ticino.  Since I am one of those people who hates the birthday thing in public this would send me running for the exit.
I think it's worth bearing in mind about that scene that he initially just asked her over dinner, with a bottle of champagne, and then she made him do the get down on one knee and offer a ring thing. So that's kind of a case of the bride making it more public than it was initially planned to be.

Venus193

  • Super Hero!
  • ****
  • Posts: 15620
  • Backstage passes are wonderful things!
Re: Public Marriage Proposals
« Reply #121 on: May 08, 2013, 01:46:45 PM »
I guess what bothered me the most about that scene is his awkwardness.

Emmy

  • Hero Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 3746
Re: Public Marriage Proposals
« Reply #122 on: May 11, 2013, 02:54:40 PM »
Quote
  I always think its weird when I read in posts that if a couple is seriously discussing marriage 'they are already engaged' (usually followed by 'why do they need a ring' or 'a proposal isn't necessary'). Seriously discussing, and even know the plan is for it to happen someday, does not mean a couple is engaged - discussing a plan and implementing a plan are two separate stages of being.

   That's exactly what inspired my question! I encountered a few posts opining that a couple who have agreed that they will one day marry are already engaged and there is 'no need' for a proposal. The combination of 'every couple should discuss marriage seriously', with 'when they agree marriage is the next step, they are engaged' pretty much kills the very concept of the proposal event, which I think is a shame, because I think proposals have a certain charm to them, and are often a great story.

 Perhaps its my masculine pride rearing its head, but I would greatly resent being deprived of the chance to execute my (entirely hypothetical) ultimate romantic proposal.

I agree with this, I am a woman and a proposal was important to me.  A female friend of mine expressed disappointment over her non-proposal.  One friend and her FH had been discussing and planning on getting engaged.  They went ring shopping together and he handed her the bag with the ring.  It sounds so anti-climatic to me.  My DH didn't do anything dramatic, we were on a visit to NYC taking a walk in Central Park, but the fact he got on one knee and asked me formally made the moment very special.  I don't consider myself a demanding woman, but I would have felt let down if he had just considered us engaged because we had talked about marriage and wanted to head in that direction.

I think the marriage conversation should come up before a proposal (both people should agree about the direction of the relationship), but simply because two people have discussed marriage doesn't automatically mean they are engaged. 

Pen^2

  • Hero Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 1107
Re: Public Marriage Proposals
« Reply #123 on: May 21, 2013, 10:51:27 AM »
Quote
  I always think its weird when I read in posts that if a couple is seriously discussing marriage 'they are already engaged' (usually followed by 'why do they need a ring' or 'a proposal isn't necessary'). Seriously discussing, and even know the plan is for it to happen someday, does not mean a couple is engaged - discussing a plan and implementing a plan are two separate stages of being.

   That's exactly what inspired my question! I encountered a few posts opining that a couple who have agreed that they will one day marry are already engaged and there is 'no need' for a proposal. The combination of 'every couple should discuss marriage seriously', with 'when they agree marriage is the next step, they are engaged' pretty much kills the very concept of the proposal event, which I think is a shame, because I think proposals have a certain charm to them, and are often a great story.

 Perhaps its my masculine pride rearing its head, but I would greatly resent being deprived of the chance to execute my (entirely hypothetical) ultimate romantic proposal.

I agree with this, I am a woman and a proposal was important to me.  A female friend of mine expressed disappointment over her non-proposal.  One friend and her FH had been discussing and planning on getting engaged.  They went ring shopping together and he handed her the bag with the ring.  It sounds so anti-climatic to me.  My DH didn't do anything dramatic, we were on a visit to NYC taking a walk in Central Park, but the fact he got on one knee and asked me formally made the moment very special.  I don't consider myself a demanding woman, but I would have felt let down if he had just considered us engaged because we had talked about marriage and wanted to head in that direction.

I think the marriage conversation should come up before a proposal (both people should agree about the direction of the relationship), but simply because two people have discussed marriage doesn't automatically mean they are engaged.

POD. No-one, including a couple, should commit to anything without properly considering it first. And when there's more than one person involved, that means discussing it together. For all one person knows, their partner is against marriage as a concept, or is strongly against the idea of certain types of proposals (e.g. public ones), or whatever. Maybe one person is expecting to have children when married and the other has always been a "no children" person. Basically: it's a huge life decision, and therefore the most important thing is whether both people are on the same page. Getting engaged means officially being committed to getting married at some future point. It needs to be discussed beforehand.

DH and I, for example, before we were married or engaged, talked a bit about things. It was all hypothetical. Largely because he was terrified that I would not want to get married or something, and once I realised this, I made sure to comment whenever there was a wedding in a film or something: "I love the way they did ..., what do you think" or "I could never do ... could you?" From there, we talked about personal preferences and beliefs and knew roughly where each other stood. A proposal before knowing those things would have been recklessly irresponsible.

If one person is going to say "yes" or "no", the other should hopefully have a good idea of it beforehand. Nothing certain is possible, of course, but at least an inkling of what the answer would be. Similarly, they should know if the other person detests public proposals or something before they commit to doing one.

GreenEyedHawk

  • Hero Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 1762
  • Not hot but SPICY
    • My Facebook.  Feel free to add me!
Re: Public Marriage Proposals
« Reply #124 on: May 21, 2013, 04:31:53 PM »
Emmy- I think your husband's proposal was very nice and very romantic.  Central Park is a lovely place and it sounds like he didn't do it with a big production...that's about the right amount of "public", in my opinion.  Yes, you were in a public place but he didn't do anything to really put you on the spot in front of hundreds of spectators.  Very nice.
"After all this time?"
"Always."

daen

  • Member
  • **
  • Posts: 498
Re: Public Marriage Proposals
« Reply #125 on: May 24, 2013, 10:55:44 PM »
Quote
  I always think its weird when I read in posts that if a couple is seriously discussing marriage 'they are already engaged' (usually followed by 'why do they need a ring' or 'a proposal isn't necessary'). Seriously discussing, and even know the plan is for it to happen someday, does not mean a couple is engaged - discussing a plan and implementing a plan are two separate stages of being.

I agree with that - my now-husband and I discussed marriage very seriously. Systematically, in fact - we went through one of those before-you-get-married books that asks questions about how each of you manages money and wants to raise children and so on. I wasn't prepared to marry him until after I had a good idea of where our areas of agreement and disagreement are.

Where I find the line gets blurry is when the not-engaged couple has put down a deposit on a reception venue for a specific date. And yes, I have heard of that happening.

Edited to clean up quoting error.

 
« Last Edit: June 03, 2013, 06:15:08 PM by daen »

ThistleBird

  • Jr. Member
  • *
  • Posts: 70
Re: Public Marriage Proposals
« Reply #126 on: June 02, 2013, 10:20:58 PM »
I've thought about what I would do if confronted with a public proposal from a guy I didn't want to marry. Partly because--how awful would that be?

1. Say "I need some time to think about it." The audience can't tell if that's a yes or a no (whether they have audio or not!), so there's no big drama.
2. Wail till you're in a more private/anonymous space.
3. Tell him "no", set him straight if he's clueless, ream him out if he's not.

I think a woman's perfectly within her rights to say "NO" in front of everybody if that's what she wants/needs to do, but I feel like my solution would make it easier on me as well as everybody else.