Hostesses With The Mostest > Recipe Requests

recipe request mushroom sauce to top steaks (and side suggestions)

(1/2) > >>

I found a really really yummy mushroom sauce for steaks a couple years ago. But, in a moment of foolishness, I forgot to bookmark it or write it down anywhere. BIL is in town, so DH and I are having him and other BIL over for dinner. I have NY Strip Steaks, and DH requested that I make the yummy mushroom sauce again. I don't remember much about it other than it had mushroom, Worcestershire, and either cream or cream cheese.

So, I thought I'd put it to ehell, and see if anyone has a really good, go-to sauce.

Oh, and I'd take suggestions for sides. I am having the hardest time pulling this menu together ::) (at myself)
I have stuff for a green salad, and mashed potatoes, of course. It's Sunday dinner, so I want to do something a little more than a normal weeknight dinner.

Dessert is going to be a berry cobbler (this one: but with fresh blue/black berries) with vanilla ice cream.

ok, for the mushroom sauce I have a fail proof super dooper easy one.

I slice up about a dozen mushrooms (more or less depending on how 'mushroomy' you want it) and throw them into a hot pan with butter. I then add about 2 teaspoons of whole grain mustard (you could replace with Worcestershire). Fry off until mushrooms are soft and starting to caramelise, and add about 200ml of thickened cream. stir until simmering and serve.

This is an awesome basic recipe. I have used field mushrooms, cream cheese, no mustard, added cheese... really the ideas are endless. I find the older cup mushrooms that are open make a much nicer sauce. I am an Aussie, so I dont know what the conversion is to ounces, but its about 1 small tub of cream - but really, I go more by look than measurements.

Steak, mushroom sauce, mashed potatoes and green salad sounds awesome to me. Maybe some grilled zucchini or asparagus to add a bit more green?

Avi, that sounds delicious. I have a pound of mushrooms from my CSA box that need to be used up soon.

Could you clarify what is thickened cream?  Is it heavy cream or is it sour cream?

I love mushroom with steak.

The first time I made some I used the recipe in my Better Homes Cookbook except I made a mistake and didn't halve the butter when I halved all the other ingredients. I realized it too late to stop. Well I've made it that way ever since.

This is unlikely to be the recipe you are looking for as it isn't really a sauce. But the mushrooms were wonderful.

Side track --

--- Quote from: twiggy on January 19, 2013, 08:40:27 PM --- DH requested that I make the yummy mushroom sauce again.

--- End quote ---

Oooooh. Yikes! I once made a yummy chicken meal (YCM). DD#1 asked for me to make it again (several months later) for her 10th b-day. I made what I thought was the YCM. DD#1 told me (very politely and not during dinner) that that wasn't the YCM she was thinking about. DD#1 is now 20 years old and I've been making chicken every which way and have never, ever been able to recreate YCM. :'(

Hopefully your mushroom sauce will be as great as the first one you made. ;D

Not much help for the recipe that you're looking for because I don't use cream. I use the portabella mushrooms, thinly sliced. Sautee in butter with some garlic and red wine vinegar. Once the mushrooms are close to done, add some beef broth/stock to deglaze the pan. Bring to a boil and add some corn starch to lightly thicken.


[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

Go to full version