After a long and hard though, I have decided that the spice grinder wins. If possible, i buy my spices whole, and grind small amounts at a time.
Nice story about my spice grinder, I got to take it from my parents place a few years ago, and I told them a few weeks ago how much I use it and love it, even though it is so old. They told me it was a wedding present (they were married 42 years ago) and my mom told the friend who gave it to them, who was pleased to hear that after all these years her gift was still used and loved.