Baby Names - You're kidding Right???

[Nikko-chan]

Saw these the other day: Codye (a girl) and the name Krystina. *whimper* Why the y? Wasn't an i good enough!?

[RegionMom]

Krystyna is Polish spelling.  Only doing part is...making your child have to correct the spelling for he rest of their life.

[Rohanna]

Krystyna is Polish spelling.  Only doing part is...making your child have to correct the spelling for he rest of their life.

Many of the posts in this thread now seem to assume that everyone is a North American of anglo-saxon origin , so different spellings are not checked to see if they are cultural, ethnic or otherwise "normal" somewhere that isn't a flyover state in America. The original premise was amusing, but now to be honest, it's made me uncomfortable to see perfectly normal names in other heritages held up for derision simply because they are unfamiliar to the poster.

[Nikko-chan]

Krystyna is Polish spelling.  Only doing part is...making your child have to correct the spelling for he rest of their life.

Many of the posts in this thread now seem to assume that everyone is a North American of anglo-saxon origin , so different spellings are not checked to see if they are cultural, ethnic or otherwise "normal" somewhere that isn't a flyover state in America. The original premise was amusing, but now to be honest, it's made me uncomfortable to see perfectly normal names in other heritages held up for derision simply because they are unfamiliar to the poster.

It's not unfamiliar. I am just wondering why a Y and an I. I can understand 2 Y's. It is the y and the I that boggles my mind. And FTR I share the name with this girl, just a different spelling. The name Christina has always boggled my mind... mainly because it has a thousand spellings.

[Hmmmmm]

Krystyna is Polish spelling.  Only doing part is...making your child have to correct the spelling for he rest of their life.

Many of the posts in this thread now seem to assume that everyone is a North American of anglo-saxon origin , so different spellings are not checked to see if they are cultural, ethnic or otherwise "normal" somewhere that isn't a flyover state in America. The original premise was amusing, but now to be honest, it's made me uncomfortable to see perfectly normal names in other heritages held up for derision simply because they are unfamiliar to the poster.

I assume you are aware that most "flyover states" have some type of very strong ethnic foundation.  Maybe not as diverse as some other coastal states, or those that you seem to deem worthy of visiting and not just flying over.  But I have met a few New Yorkers who have no idea how to deal with Kuykendahl.  It seems some people forget that Maine, New Hampshire, and Vermont are some of the least diverse states in the nation.  And California as an extremely small eastern european population.

Sorry if this seems snippy, but I find the term fly over state very dismissive even though I do not live in one.

[RegionMom]

Yikes-
I wrote the Polish Krystyna comment on my phone, and now that it has been quoted, cannot correct the poor way I wrote it!
Krystyna is a heritage name for some of my family.

I meant to say,
Krystyna is the Polish spelling for the name Christina, although it is not so common in the US.  The hard part is having the child give the "correct" spelling of their version of the name for the rest of their life--Krystina, Christina, Kristina, Kristyna, Khristina, Khrystyna, Chrystyna, Kristiana, Chrystiana, Crystyna, Cristina, etc...
(only three of those names I wrote were ok with spellcheck.)

My own name is phonetically easy, but not common.

I do not think there is a "perfect" name. 
I bet even Adam and Eve had to spell out their names!  lol

[stitchygreyanonymouse]

Well, it wasn’t until the last three hundred years or so (maybe less in areas with lower literacy rates) that spelling was standardized… even for names. so Adam might have been comfortable with Adom, Adem, Addam, or Aadam.

[joraemi]

I have not ever had a reason to post to this thread until recently!

I worked in a school building a few weeks ago where there was a plethora of twins.  One set of the twins was named (*names changed - you'll see the point anyway...*): Jimmy Joe Bob I and Jimmy Joe Bob II.

 

[athersgeo]

When my father was a boy, he encountered a couple of odd names. One was the name of a fellow pupil:
[redacted] Goodwilly
The other, the name of the doctor's receptionist:
Mrs Death (pronounced De-ath)

Meanwhile his mother's first name was Gwenna - a name that I rather like, but, by all accounts, she absolutely hated.

Then there was Aunty Daisy - who was neither an aunt nor actually Christened Daisy...never DID get to the bottom of that one, though! (I've a notion that Daisy might be some connection to the name Margaret, but I'm not positive.)

Finally, there's me: Rachel. Six letters. Nice and simple. Even if you can't read the block capitals on the form, you can at least COUNT them...unless you were the admin team of the University of Salford Acoustics department, who spent two years insisting that my name was RachAel. (More than ten years later and I'm still annoyed by that one...and grateful that I didn't finish my degree because I'd have been even more irritated had my degree certificate been misspelled!)

Interestingly, in my year at secondary school (roughly 60 girls), we actually got off lightly for "unique" names, but boy was there duplication: Three girls called Jo, three called Lucy (admittedly one of those was a Lucy-Ann rather than just Lucy), four Rach(a)els (two of us Rachel Jane!), three Jessicas, three (or was it four?) Catherine/Kathryn/Katherines (yes, each one had a different spelling!), two Sophies, two Amy/Aimees (and just to confuse the issue, Amy had an older sister called Jo who also went there so sometimes she'd cop for Jo instead), a Hannah and an Anna...and that's just what I can remember!

Mind you, the group of girls who started aged eleven when I was finishing off my a-levels contained (so I'm told - I'd actually moved schools by then) five girls called Kylie...yes, as in Minogue.

[blue2000]

When my father was a boy, he encountered a couple of odd names. One was the name of a fellow pupil:
[redacted] Goodwilly
The other, the name of the doctor's receptionist:
Mrs Death (pronounced De-ath)

Meanwhile his mother's first name was Gwenna - a name that I rather like, but, by all accounts, she absolutely hated.

Then there was Aunty Daisy - who was neither an aunt nor actually Christened Daisy...never DID get to the bottom of that one, though! (I've a notion that Daisy might be some connection to the name Margaret, but I'm not positive.)

Daisy is indeed a nickname for Margaret. It was fairly common years ago but it has fallen out of favour so most people don't know it.

Fun fact - there are several sequels to the book 'Little Women'. In one of them we meet Meg's twins, Margaret and John, named after their parents. They get the nicknames Daisy and Demi (as in demi-john).

[artk2002]

The other, the name of the doctor's receptionist:
Mrs Death (pronounced De-ath)

There's a famous fictional detective whose middle name is Death (rhymes with "teeth.") Lord Peter Death Bredon Wimsey

[stitchygreyanonymouse]

Finally, there's me: Rachel. Six letters. Nice and simple. Even if you can't read the block capitals on the form, you can at least COUNT them...unless you were the admin team of the University of Salford Acoustics department, who spent two years insisting that my name was RachAel. (More than ten years later and I'm still annoyed by that one...and grateful that I didn't finish my degree because I'd have been even more irritated had my degree certificate been misspelled!)

Likewise, we RachAels are forever trying to correct people who insist our name is Rachel 

My degrees are all right, but any number of other important documents are wrong or had to be corrected. Bah.

[athersgeo]

Finally, there's me: Rachel. Six letters. Nice and simple. Even if you can't read the block capitals on the form, you can at least COUNT them...unless you were the admin team of the University of Salford Acoustics department, who spent two years insisting that my name was RachAel. (More than ten years later and I'm still annoyed by that one...and grateful that I didn't finish my degree because I'd have been even more irritated had my degree certificate been misspelled!)

Likewise, we RachAels are forever trying to correct people who insist our name is Rachel 

My degrees are all right, but any number of other important documents are wrong or had to be corrected. Bah.

Believe me, I sympathise!

[Coruscation]

The other, the name of the doctor's receptionist:
Mrs Death (pronounced De-ath)

There's a famous fictional detective whose middle name is Death (rhymes with "teeth.") Lord Peter Death Bredon Wimsey

I read somewhere that names like this are from the Middle Ages when parts in religious plays were highly coveted and passed down the generations. It accounts for names like Death, Virgin, Priest etc.

[LazyDaisy]

I always thought it had to do with using a person's occupation as a surname: Cooper, Chandler, Smith, Tailor/Taylor. I can see where Death might have been the name given to grave diggers or executioners etc.