I'm from Wisconsin. I get the same reaction when I tell people I love Wisconsin..
I don't know what part of the state you're from, but I've been to Madison and the surrounding area twice and absolutely LOVED it. 
Madison is nice, but Milwaukee is great too! Lots of museums and the lake. Plus Summerfest, State fair and a summer full of festivals of every kind!
I grew up near Milwaukee, went to college in Eau Claire, and now live in Madison. They are all wonderful cities, for very different reasons.
DF and I live in Chicago, and we're planning to honeymoon in New Glarus, WI. We've wanted to go for awhile, and since nobody's offered to sponsor two weeks in the Bahamas (

), we figured it was the perfect opportunity. We're both looking forward to eating a lot of cheese, drinking a lot of Spotted Cow, and exploring the town. It hasn't really come up in conversation yet, but I'm curious about what sort of reactions we'll get, though I expect my family to disappoint me by being completely supportive.
