Close

Just Say “No, Thank You”

I’m writing mostly for help. I have a horrible track record of ending up in ehell where showers are concerned and I’m worried I’ll end up with yet another one. I’m hoping maybe you can help me protect myself. I may be worrying over nothing however. I’m pregnant with my second child. I’m mostly afraid a friend of mine will decide to throw me a shower and I’ll be unable to get out of it. She had a Gender Reveal/Sprinkle for her own second child. And if she offers I’m not sure how to decline without telling her I believe showers for 2nd children in most cases are tacky. But I can’t tell her that since she had a shower for her 2nd child in a manner I found extra tacky, and it would be rude to let on I felt that way.

If it helps here’s my past shower offenses. Please feel free to edit as needed or even leave out entirely. For our Wedding, my husband and I had to move the date up by about 6 months suddenly because of the economy. As such I had about 2 months to plan/replan the wedding. I chopped my guest list and switched to the chapel at our church (instead of the larger sanctuary), so that I could get a room at a nice restaurant for the reception instead of trying to find a caterer and a hall. Well, our church women’s group always held showers for brides and 1st time mothers-to-be. When the lady in charge of Women’s ministries contacted me about the shower I told her I wasn’t going to have one since I didn’t have the time and could not invite the whole church like most of the couple from the church did when they got married. (This is generally an insert in the bulletin saying anyone in the church is welcome to attend the wedding at date and time, not full formal invitations to each member.) Well she insisted they had to have a shower for me since it’ll cause problems in the church if they start having them for some people and not others. Well, I didn’t feel right about causing problems for her by refusing so I let her have it. So the big faux pas was having a shower where the vast majority of the guests were not invited to the wedding.

For my first baby I had two showers, which is a bit tacky in and of itself, but the only overlap of people was myself, my mom, and my sister-in-law, so not too awful. The first one was a family/friends shower. My aunt, and cousin planned it with some help from my mom. I know family is not supposed to plan showers, but they didn’t ask me if they could. They called me up one day with a theme picked out, decorations already bought, and some progress on the games and food to pin down a date that worked for me. This was the first I’d heard of it. My aunt and cousin are both pretty strapped for money and I didn’t know how to tell them that it was rude for them to host the shower and all their work and money spent was for nothing, so I went along with it. Doubly so because this aunt was a huge help while I was crash planning the wedding. She called and set up appointments for me with florists, restaurants, and cake places while I was at work. (She was basically housebound on disability at the time) They are both people who just love to do for others and are not generally people I would consider presumptuous or controlling. I certainly didn’t feel any need to nip anything in the bud. 3 years later, I can say I was right about that.

The church shower, they asked my parents small group to plan for me. So the only real faux pas was my mother was again in the thick of the planning. Again it was half planned before anyone said anything to me about it. I’d say it was less of a faux pas in this case since as I stated before the church had showers for ALL first time moms anyway.

The church isn’t a concern this time around since A. they only do stuff for first time moms and B. We no longer go there. Our current church doesn’t do anything for moms, there are much too many of them. My family/friends shower was rather early (the Saturday before Thanksgiving) because I was due February 5th, but at high risk for pre-term labor and my aunt wanted it before her surgery scheduled on the Saturday after Thanksgiving. Also we wanted to avoid Christmas craziness. None of my friends offered to or hinted they were planning a shower last time, but with the early shower I’m afraid they just got beat to the punch. Hopefully, I’m worried over nothing. But I really don’t want to get caught unprepared again. 1127-13

It is possible to get out of attending a baby shower in your honor without explaining to anyone that you consider second and more showers to be an etiquette faux.  When asked for a date that would be convenient for you be in attendance at a shower, sigh and say, “It looks like my calendar is full .”    That won’t prevent a surprise shower and to be honest, you shouldn’t expect one.   But if it happens, be gracious.  A good friend surprised me with a baby shower for my second child. I had no idea and was totally caught off guard when I opened the door to her home and met a dozen women yelling “Surprise!”  You go with the flow and behave kindly.

BaByQ Dilemma

I’m facing a potentially awkward social situation and I need help knowing what to say!

My sister Sue is pregnant, her second child, but almost 18 years difference in age. She is employed with a well paying job, doesn’t pay rent due to living in a family home, the father Tom is in the picture, and she kept all of her baby furniture and items from my niece – I say this to emphasize that she is in no way financially in need. Sue, though, does not always make the best choices and has a tendency to use others – the pregnancy has only exacerbated this behavior i.e. at the 3 month mark she was trying to schedule family members once the baby is born (scheduled c-section so she could calendar down to the day) for what weeks she expects them to come take care of her, clean the house, and take care of the baby. Most of the family has long grown exhausted by this type of behavior and are polite but firm in not feeding into the gimme gimme behavior. Half of the family are barely speaking with her at present due to several recent choices in this vein, and the other half were extremely reluctant to participate in a baby shower for similar reasons, so we tried to strike a compromise. This last Christmas we all agreed to only buy presents for the children in the family and in lieu of a shower we included Baby Girl to Be, so Sue received quite a few baby gifts for Christmas (while still complaining that she only received baby gifts from the other adults and that the children should have bought gifts specifically for her in return). She was told and well aware that this was replacing a baby shower.

Now a month later we’ve all received invitations (including relatives who obviously live too far away to attend) to a BaByQ being hosted by Tom’s mother, billed as an event for everyone to come together to celebrate the happy occasion, but also with an emphasis on where they’re registered for baby gifts. I’ve RSVP’d to attend because Sue really wants us to meet Tom’s family, and my niece really wants support being around Tom and his family – but I will not be giving her more gifts than I already have. This will almost certainly become an issue, possibly loudly and with much drama and angst at the occasion – I say this because Sue is almost 40 years old but still counts, compares, and keeps a running tally of her gifts at every birthday and Christmas to other peoples’ gifts, and complains at what she always considers to be a disparity. She has already casually mentioned how no one seems to have bought gifts off her registry at BabysRUs – all of which are very expensive, usually the most expensive options – instead buying gifts at other stores.

I’m not sure what to say if she does make a scene of it, and I also don’t want Tom’s family to believe we’re all cheapskates who won’t give baby gifts. I’ve had several other family members also calling for advice, who want to meet his family but share the same concerns. Is there any way we can keep from creating a bad first impression with our hosts and what can I say if she makes a scene in front of everyone? 0202-17

“BaByQ”.   Well, that’s a first.   I’ve never heard the word before this. If it weren’t explicitly tied to gift giving I’d be inclined to approve of it as an alternative to repetitive baby showers.

As for caring what in-laws think, this will be one of those situations where you quietly, and confidently, rest in the truth that you know what the true score is.  You don’t need to justify to anyone what your gift giving is or was or may be.    It’s none of their  business.    I admit to feeling a perverse pleasure in quietly harboring a secret truth while those around me make unfounded and ugly assumptions because I am confident that eventually the truth will be known.    You shouldn’t presume Tom’s family are shallow, materialistic, and petty either but rather that they can recognize a gimme pig as well as you can.

If your family attends the BaByQ, it will be viewed as being respectful to Tom’s side of the family, being supportive of the new baby and family connections and indicative of a willingness to be civil to the in-laws who will share the love of this baby.  And for heaven’s sake, do mingle and greet Tom’s family as opposed to everyone sitting in their respective family corners.

If Sue makes a scene, I can’t imagine it being perceived as anything other than a tantrum for not getting loads of presents and that’s not going to reflect well on her.  Let her rant, meaning  “give her lots of rope” to hang herself further.   Getting into an argument defending yourselves won’t accomplish anything because her pride will be a barrier to her admitting that you or some other designated family is right. Sue isn’t going to have an epiphany in front of both sides of the family saying, “Oh you are right!   I did get a lot of baby gifts for Christmas!  How silly of me to forget!”

Anything Worth Having Is Worth Working Hard To Get It

Hello Ms. Jeanne,
Today’s gimme pig story got me thinking about something that popped up on my Facebook feed last week. My husband and I know a couple who has been struggling to conceive a child for several years. They decided about 3 years ago that they would most likely adopt. I guess they decided the time is right, because just last week the wife of the couple posted on Facebook about how they’re ready to adopt with a link to a donation page to help them raise the $28,000 it will cost them to adopt a baby.

What are your thoughts on this?

Personally, it rubs me the wrong way, because not only have they had several years to save up this money, but they also are asking us to pay for their choice to have a child. Expectant mothers who are having a rough financial time don’t go around asking friends and family to pay their delivery bills for their birth. Additionally, she has posted the same link several times since then. Not many people have donated, and they have collected only a few hundred dollars. Seems like other people agree with me.

Of course, it would be terribly rude to say anything, but I sure do hope that they get the hint when they realize that they don’t have anywhere near enough donations to proceed without saving money themselves. 1014-16

It’s a crying shame that adoption costs so much money.  Children desperately in need of a family should not have such a high price tag.   That said, kids are expensive regardless of how they arrive in the family.   My last c-section was 28 years ago and cost $8,000 and I’m sure it’s even more expensive now.   While insurance did cover a lot of the expense, there was still a sizeable co-pay required from us.   We did not go fundraising among friends and family to pay the delivery bills.

Anything worth having is worth working hard to get.   Often gratification is delayed because the necessary means are not available to achieve what we want so time is invested to work towards that goal.  The desired thing is all the more precious and sweeter when it comes about as the result of sacrifice and hard work.

The Mainstream Media Endorses Entitlement

I’m pregnant with our first child and have been excited at all the information that I am learning to prepare for our special one!  I recently had this e-mail sent to me from a popular parenting magazine and was so glad that I follow Etiquette Hell!

It’s no wonder more and more people think it’s okay to throw their own baby shower when articles like this show up!

http://www.parents.com/baby/shower/planning/modern-baby-shower/?sssdmh=dm17.901024&esrc=nwpdpregrec_wk18d148

Under the question:   Who should throw my baby shower? it reads: “If you’re really into party planning or everyone else in your life is just too busy, go ahead and plan your shower yourself — just ask a friend to send the invites and gather the RSVPs”.

So basically, if I don’t think my friends are going to step up and give me all the stuff that I deserve as a new mom, then it’s okay for me to throw a party and say, “GIMMEE!!” Sheesh!

Thanks for all you do to educate people on etiquette! 0406-16

The sense of entitlement is not diminishing and the media is an accomplice to the growing expectation that one deserves to receive gifts from people by any means necessary.  We are slowly becoming a nation of people who habitually have their hand out expecting to be given things that our ancestors worked hard to provide for themselves.

Have A Baby! Get Free Food, Maid Service And Errands Done!

Okay, so I’m just starting to tell folks I’m pregnant. I admit to being woefully under prepared/educated about showers and their etiquette. I have a friend who’s stepped forward to coordinate the shower. Another thing she’s offered to do is coordinate a “care calendar” for me and my husband when our daughter arrives. She apparently set such a thing up for another couple at their behest. I went to check it out, and my gimmie pig alert is screeching in my head.

Like I said, I don’t know if this is ‘the thing to do’ or what. But my feeling is that I know that motherhood will be difficult, I know that I will probably alternately want visitors while probably also wanting to retreat to a cave of hormonal puddles and lack of showering. I also think that I’m a grownup who can do stuff like prepare frozen meals ahead of time and use my lips for asking for things of close friends and relatives. In addition, while I’ll be stressed and tired, I will, to my knowledge, not have any significant medical problems (save a potential for a c-section), nor will I magically be disabled.

Anyway, this care calendar of the other couple basically has months worth of sign ups for people to bring meals to the couple, along with requests on the weekends for running errands and do housecleaning. Along with the meal sign ups, it says “please put the meal in the cooler on the back steps.” In addition, people who supply these favors do not earn an audience with the wee child they’re doing all this for. The parents have stated that volunteers are not to expect that they will answer the door, allow visitors to hold/see the baby, or any kind of “thanks for stopping by, we really appreciate it.” The rationale for this is that the baby’s immune system is too weak/young.

This strikes me as inappropriate. I went to nursing school, and did exceptionally well in the OB section (because I didn’t like it and I therefore made myself study it harder), and am aware that babies have fledgling baby immune systems that take a few weeks/months to kick into gear. Having said that, I think it’s highly inappropriate and presumptuous to tell your friends that “you’re good enough to cook/clean/run errands for us, but you’re too disease carrying to actually meet the baby.” I will grant you that I’ve never done this before, but even if I’m tired as hell, I would HOPE that I could muster the social graces to COME TO THE DOOR AND THANK SOMEONE WHO DROPPED A MEAL OFF FOR ME. Or that if someone offered to clean the house or run to the store for me, that they would earn the right to hold my baby. In addition, this is something that is being solicited by the parents through the shower coordinator, and being sent to shower guests, who presumably have already bought gifts and wished the couple well.

I’m seriously leaning towards telling my friend to please not bother on my behalf, that if I need help, I will ask for it. But then again, maybe people don’t think of this as weird. I’ve never heard of it, and would love your or your reader’s advice.   0112-16

The use of “care calendars” or online sign up sites can serve a practical purpose, particularly if there is a significant need such as after a c-section (it is major surgery), a baby born with medical problems requiring the parents to be at the hospital much longer than expected, or even death.   Not knowing the circumstances of the other couple who received “months worth of sign up” opportunities, I can’t outright condemn what I do not know.  Do they need that level of care?  Is mom experiencing significant postpartum depression?

For the typical birth, yes, I concur that it seems excessive to rally volunteers to bring meals for months.    Two weeks is the standard in my circle and even then the meals are arranged to be brought every other or third day so as to avoid a mountain of leftovers.   I’ve never known of a sign up to help a new mother do errands or clean her house unless the baby or mom is in the hospital for an extended stay.

So, humor your friend and consent to a care calendar that brings you meals every other day or every third day for 2 weeks after the birth.   Those who really want to bring you food will have the opportunity to do so but it’s not an excessive demand on people’s time.    Decline the errand and housecleaning services since that implies your husband is incapable of doing these tasks.    As for people seeing or holding the new baby, don’t get too “new mom” obsessive about it. Back when I had my first child, it was common for new moms to not come to church with new babies for four to six weeks.   By my third child, we had her out in public by five days old.   All the new moms of my acquaintance bring new babies to church within days of birth where they are ooohed and aahed over.   It’s fine to restrict who holds the baby if they have an active sniffle or cough or even ask people to use hand sanitizer before holding the swaddled baby.    When a new grandchild is born, that baby gets handed up and down the church pew all during the service with none suffering ill effects.