That restaurant owner shaming the OP story reminded me of this.
My husband and I went to a new little sandwich shop in town to try it out. We both ordered a burger and fries. It was about one in the afternoon, so we weren’t surprised to see only one couple, who were about to leave, as most people here get 12 to one off for lunch. We noticed that several tables had not yet been bused, but there was only one waitress in this tiny place, and she started cleaning them as we sat down.
Our burgers came quickly enough, and I bit into mine just before my husband did. He had his burger to his mouth but I immediately said, “Stop.” I explained that the meat in my burger didn’t taste like beef – or pork – or chicken – or turkey – or even vegetarian, all of which I’ve eaten. I can’t even explain what it tasted like – not spoiled, just … odd. He couldn’t resist trying a bite and quickly agreed with me. We signaled to the waitress, and I explained that our burgers tasted funny – they didn’t taste like beef. She assured me it was good freshly ground chuck. I said again that they didn’t taste like beef and we didn’t feel comfortable eating them. Her response, with a patronizing smile, was, “You’ve probably never had really good ground chuck before, just plain old cheap hamburger.”
I kept my temper, but I told her I’d eaten plenty of good beef, and this wasn’t it, and we needed our checks. She refused to comp our meal, and only gave us a discount on our glasses of tea. My husband, who was paying, finally said fine, but we’d never be back. As we were walking out, my husband pointed to the tables she was clearing, and asked if I had noticed that all of them had plenty of food left on the plates. The shop was closed in less than three months after it opened. I still wonder what it was they were serving as “beef.” 0115-19
My first thought was to wonder if the beef was grass-fed. Pasture raised beef comes with a hefty price tag as being more organic but it definitely can have a taste to it that some people dislike.
You called the waitress over and complained that the burgers did not taste right, not that you suspected spoilage. Had you used the words “tastes spoiled” in your communication with her, this would have escalated the situation to one that should be taken very seriously by any restaurant owner. Failure of the staff to address the possible serving of spoiled meat could have been resolved by requesting a leftover box be brought to your table with the stated intention that you are delivering the burgers to the Health Department to determine if the meat is, in fact, spoiling.
In the situation where you cannot detect that the food is spoiled but rather you don’t like how the food tastes, I believe the common response is to pay for the meal, leaving food uneaten if you choose to, declaring to yourself that you’ll never eat there again and possibly write a detailed food review of the restaurant.